Toodyay Herald

Former deputy president Beth Ruthven lost her re-election bid with 72 votes (4.6 per cent of all primary votes cast), as did former Cr Susan Pearce with 150 votes (9.6 per cent).

Both were beaten by newcomer Ray Mills who polled 174 votes (11.1 per cent) but it was not enough to win him a council seat.

Toodyay’s new seven-member council met two days later to swear in the three newly elected councillors and conduct a secret ballot in the chamber to elect a presiding officer and deputy for the next two years.

Cr Dival, who campaigned on a platform of change, nominated Cr McKeown for shire president, and former president Madacsi announced her intent to re-contest the role.

There were no other candidates.

Cr McKeown won the secret ballot in what was understood to be a 4-3 vote.

Cr Prater then nominated fellow newcomer Cr Dival for deputy president, and sitting Cr Steve McCormick nominated Cr Madacsi.

Cr Madacsi declined the nomination, leaving Cr Dival to be elected unopposed as new Shire Deputy President.

Shire President McKeown closed the meeting after lots were drawn for new seating positions around the council table.

Ms Haslehurst said the contractor gave no explanation for the delay but apologised and provided a discount for the errors.

Tip passes were also missing from some envelopes, prompting the shire to require proof of local residence at the Toodyay recycling depot for free rubbish disposal.

A different contractor had misprinted shire payment notices, omitting the first three digits on some account numbers.

“It was no fault of the shire,” Ms Haslehurst said.”

“The solution is to insert ‘100’ in front of any seven-digit numbers.”

They live in the Moondyne area of west Julimar amid gently rolling hills and trees in what was until recently an idyllic setting.

That was before Perth-based Chalice Mining bought 2500ha (6200 acres) of nearby farmland to build a Kalgoorlie-sized super pit, starting in 2026.

The miner says it currently houses up to 30 workers at the site and averages 72 vehicle movements a day, seven days a week, on 2.3km of unsealed Keating Road that links local residents’ homes to the outside world.

One family says dust has affected the health of their three-year-old son who travels the same road twice a day to attend pre-school.

Another local resident who runs a bush writers’ retreat on a 30ha (75 acres) property said Chalice had offered them $300,000 in compensation while farmers with land needed for mining got millions of dollars.

“Such a small amount of money wouldn’t buy even a 200sqm block in Balga,” she said.

“We grow our own vegies and the dust gets into everything, even the dog bowl,” a third resident with an art gallery and pottery said.

Ä couple with their own vineyard said their plans for bush chalet accommodation for up to 40 guests for weddings were now ruined.

“We came here to build our dream homes and live creative lifestyles in a pristine environment and now this,” one owner said.

A Chalice spokesperson said all land purchases and offers were based on a “dollar per hectare purchase price metric calculated at a substantial premium to market”.

“Larger farming properties have been acquired for a much higher price than smaller properties,” Chalice said.

The miner had set a 60km/h speed limit for workers on Keating Road and was operating a daily water cart on the gravel surface.

Dust levels measured from April to June were within national air quality guidelines and would be further monitored this summer.

Noise levels would be assessed next year when State mining approvals were sought.

World class?

We built our dream homes in Julimar for its unrivalled peace, tranquility, stunning star-filled clear skies and natural bush habitat long before Chalice Mining arrived at our doorstep.

This truly “world class” part of the world is blessed with spotted quolls, red-tailed black cockatoos, echidnas, emus and a host of wildflowers.

Chalice Mining recently boasted that there will be at least “$18 billion forecast contribution to gross state product, including royalties and direct economic contributions to the region” with “everyone benefitting” from such lofty returns.

Everyone?

Low impact?

As landowners who live within a radius of three kilometres from the site, we now have 24/7 noise, light pollution, and traffic.

Our houses are covered in dust all through summer because of a massive increase in mine-related traffic on local gravel roads.

Our already pot-holed and rutted access to the wider world is not designed for the frequency or size of the vehicles it is now carrying, and this is before construction or actual mining has even begun.

We shudder to think of the permanent health implications for children and adults who live in the area.

From October to April, a layer of dust covers our homes, our drinking water and the vegetables we grow, and we are breathing it in every day.

When mining does start and millions of tonnes of waste will pile up in large tailings dumps, with the dust will likely contain silica by-products and fibrous materials akin to asbestos.

If dust pollution is already an issue, imagine how much more will this be amplified in the years ahead?

What long-term, perhaps even deadly, effects or outcomes will we face?

Community engagement?

The occasional misleading email, a “tour” of the site with sandwiches, and a questionable survey which included ‘locals’ from Northam, Bindoon and Bullsbrook does not constitute local community engagement.

Our complaints about aircraft flying directly overhead, constant noise and light pollution go unheeded.

We have strange and uninvited vehicles entering our bush properties and contractors running residents off the road and scaring our animals.

The constant stress and anxiety from knowing that our plans for creative income, retirement and the loss of the serenity that we once enjoyed is all-consuming.

While we understand that you cannot stop progress and one can see that this project will be a financial boon for our local shire, State Government and Australian economy, we appear to be acceptable collateral damage.

If Chalice Mining is as community-minded as it says, you would think it would have engaged with us to offer compensation commensurate with the value it has placed on its Julimar mineral deposit.

When Chalice Mining shareholders reap the benefit from this publicly owned resource, remember that digging a massive open cut mine in our backyard comes at the expense of the forest, endangered animals and the locals who were here first.

To finish, here are a few words from Chalice.

“Chalice has engaged early, actively and transparently to build respectful and collaborative relationships with stakeholders.

“Chalice is committed to achieving lasting social and economic benefits for the communities in which we operate.”

Really?

When assessing disruptive impact, the frequency and type of noise – continuous or intermittent – must also be considered.

If crushing or other processing occurs, the base noise level will be considerably higher.

In the 1960s I was involved in establishing noise footprints around European airports when new Boeing 707 passenger aircraft were initially banned due to noise emissions.

Similar work should be done here.

However the most important factor relates to increased transport needs and its effect on the living environment.

Chalice Mining says it plans to extract up to 30 million tonnes of ore every year at Julimar for an initial 18-year period.

This equates to 30 trains up to 1.5km long – or 3000 large trucks – every 24 hours.

Access roads or conveyors would be needed to transport the ore to a railhead and a new standard-gauge rail line would be needed to connect it to the existing network.

My experience as Westrail Operations Research Leader in the early 1980s suggests the existing rail network can’t handle such an increase.

It represents twice the amount of grain already being railed to WA ports each year.

Significant new storage and loading infrastructure would be needed.

Current rail access to Kwinana is limited to perhaps an extra five trains per day at most.
Construction of new roads and railway lines creates extra noise at intrusive levels.

The impact of mining on flora in environmentally sensitive areas may be obvious but damage to animal life may be harder to detect.

These factors need to be investigated before it is too late to stop or limit the project.

We may need certain metals to help reduce climate change but the minerals are available in far less-sensitive environments further from cities, state forests and national parks.

The level of damage that may have already occurred at Chalice Mining’s Julimar test-drilling sites – including on private farmland – needs to be independently tested.

The Avon Valley Environmental Society, of which I have been Treasurer for many years, has met Chalice Mining several times in the past year or so.

At our first meeting about 18 months ago, we gave Chalice Mining a list of questions.
No answers have been forthcoming.

*The author is a university qualified noise expert who has worked in the British aviation and WA rail transport industries.

Chalice Mining later told The Herald that it answered a list of questions last November and is “continuing to investigate” other questions posed about the impact of a mine.