Mystery Toodyay referees recommend discredited former CEO for new top job

TWO anonymous Toodyay referees have helped former shire CEO Stan Scott to secure a new highly paid job as Cuballing Shire CEO after 15 adverse findings against him were tabled in the WA Parliament less than two years ago.

Mr Scott was publicly censured for financial mismanagement, failures under local government law, conflict of interest and unethical conduct in seven years of mistakes and lapses that cost Toodyay ratepayers hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Former Toodyay councillors – the last of whom departed last October – were blamed for their ongoing failure as employers to manage Mr Scott’s performance.

It is understood some former councillors rejected the findings as “unfair”.

It is understood none of Toodyay’s current councillors or CEO provided the referee reports.

Read more

Shire software rip-off

IN 2019 the Shire of Toodyay purchased a new financial management software program for no apparent reason.

The State Auditor General, though critical of many aspects of Shire financial reporting, indicated that the shire’s computer accounting system was adequate and not at fault.

The contract was awarded ‘behind closed doors’ to New Zealand company Datacom Pty Ltd by a unanimous council decision.

It should be stated that none of the present councillors were elected members at that time, and the Shire CEO was Stan Scott, who resigned the following year.

Read more

Geoff Appleby
Toodyay

Not just the quoll

JULIMAR Conservation Park is home to at least six listed threatened species and last month’s Page 1 article about Chalice Mining’s bid to clear their habitat needs correction.

The article focuses on the Western Quoll (Chuditch) which is not ‘endangered’ but ‘vulnerable’ and totally omits the presence of colonies of the ‘critically endangered’ Woylie, ‘endangered’ Black-flanked Rock Wallaby and the ‘vulnerable’ Carnaby’s Black Cockatoo, Baudin’s Black Cockatoo and Forest Red-tailed Black Cockatoo.

Julimar Conservation Park is one of the most significant woodland conservation areas north of Perth and represents one of the only sizeable areas of mixed jarrah and marri woodland that has not been cleared for farming, mining or traversed by roads.

Four conservation significant flora species are also found in the area earmarked for exploration and it is well-documented that increased vehicle movements spread dieback.

Read more

Nikkola Palmer
Toodyay

Ironic impact

AS RESIDENTS of Toodyay we are deeply concerned about the impact of a potentially huge mining project at Julimar State Forest and particularly Julimar Conservation Park.

It seems ironic and indeed quite wrong that the excavation of “green” minerals could have a destructive impact on the already endangered plant and animal species.

Struggling for survival against climate change are many species especially the chuditch and the beautiful black cockatoos and they are meant to be being protected there.

It also seems unfair that land belonging in effect to the people of Western Australia can be raided to make billions of dollars when, as the editor wrote in last month’s Herald editorial, “much of that wealth is likely to disappear overseas”.

Read more

Sally and Jim Scott.
Toodyay

$74m bid to mine Julimar home of rare endangered chuditch

By Michael Sinclair-Jones

CHALICE Mining has begun drilling 70 test holes in Julimar State Forest as part of a $74 million bid to turn the nature conservation park into a “globally significant” mine worth billions of dollars.

The forest is home to one of the state’s healthiest remaining populations of the rare western quoll, commonly known by its Noongar name chuditch (pictured left), which is listed as an endangered species at risk of extinction.

Chalice has already drilled 700 holes on private farmland it bought south of the forest in 2020 and plans to drill hundreds more in the nearby conservation park later this year.

The Perth-based miner told the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) on January 28 that it had obtained “key WA State Government approvals” to test “exciting targets along the extensive Julimar complex”.

Read more

Toodyay kids splash out on town’s cool new water slide

Lifeguard Luke Pringle ended up with sore arms keeping kids happy at Toodyay’s new floating playground last month – next time he will use a hose. Toodyay Aquatic Centre’s latest attraction takes about 30 minutes to inflate and will be used on Sunday afternoons if not too windy. The $13,000 play equipment was funded by Chalice Mining.

Ukraine invasion likely to affect farmers

LAST month’s Russian invasion of Ukraine in likely to result in higher fertiliser, fuel and herbicide costs for Toodyay farmers. The price of wheat and canola – already at near-record highs – is also expected to rise due to US-led trade sanctions against Russia.

By Frank Panizza, Toodyay Agriculural Alliance

The war in Ukraine, although a long way from home, has ramifications right here in Toodyay.

The tragedy of the needless loss of life and suffering is obvious, and economic impacts will be widespread and will be felt worldwide.

Ukraine and Russia export a very large amount of grain to world markets.

The two countries export on average 60,000,000 tonnes of wheat all via the Black Sea, often referred to as the Black Sea ports.

The passage from the Black Sea into the Mediterranean, and then to world markets is via a narrow straight situated near Istanbul, which in places is only 300 metres wide.

The Black Sea ports export 30 per cent of the world’s wheat, easily eclipsing Australian  wheat exports (pictured above at Esperance).

Read more

Councillor questions $450,000 rec centre ‘discrepancy’

By Michael Sinclair-Jones

TOODYAY ratepayers will not know the final cost of the shire’s new $14.5 million recreation centre until next month after a $450,000 “overspend” was questioned at last month’s shire council meeting.

Cr Mick McKeown asked where the extra money had come from, why it was needed and questioned other discrepancies in shire accounts, including a failure to submit monthly statements of financial activity to the council for last July and August.

He asked if the shire had breached local government law and for Shire CEO Suzie Haslehurst to reveal the outcome of an internal shire audit conducted last May.

Ms Haslehurst said the audit had not identified any anomalies or unusual payments and further answers would be given at the council’s April 27 meeting.

She told The Herald later that the delays and discrepancies were due to flaws in the shire’s new computerised accounts system.

Read more
1 28 29 30 31 32 58