Recording a fail: what the Shire of Toodyay’s electors meeting really revealed

OPINION

By Rashelle Predovnik
March 2026

Transparency in local government shouldn’t be controversial and in 2026 it shouldn’t even be a question.
Yet at the annual meeting of electors, residents had front row seats to an argument between the chair and a resident about what was or wasn’t said at last year’s meeting.
The reason?
There was no recording.

If it matters record it and make that information easy to find

From January 2025, shires have been required to record their council meetings, and this helps to create an accurate public record, including a record of what the shire does well.
At this elector’s meeting, the manager of finance delivered an interesting presentation that outlined issues the shire had identified and fixed.
He talked about the money saved, in what was a positive story about the responsible management of public funds.
Yet there is no record of that presentation on the shire’s website.
When The Herald asked for those details so our readers could be informed about those savings, the shire president told us to find it ourselves.
He said, “the executive manager provided examples in his presentation at the annual electors meeting, all of which are documented in previous minutes of ordinary council meetings.”
That response may have technically answered the question – but does directing our readers to trawl through a year’s worth of old minutes really serve the public interest?
The information we asked for was already available in a document that could have easily been emailed.
Instead, we were told to comb through the archives of past council minutes without dates, page numbers or agenda references – to reconstruct what the shire had already presented on PowerPoint slides.
Transparency should not require detective work.

Hit record for the record

In this case, recording matters because public meetings are not private conversations – they are part of the official democratic record.
The shire’s website notes there is no legal requirement to record the annual meeting of electors and although that is technically true – it misses the point.
Good governance is about doing more than the bare legal minimum.
Recording this annual elector meeting didn’t require a new policy, new equipment or extra funding.
It just required the shire to wheel out the same recording equipment it uses for council meetings or even a mobile phone at a push.
Instead, the room was left listening to two conflicting versions of the same event with no ability to review a recording.
And this incident summed up a broader problem on display that night.

An open forum with the floor closed

The annual meeting of electors is a forum for residents to ask questions, raise motions, and discuss general business.
Apart from this editor, only ten ratepayers attended and only two questions were submitted to the shire in advance.
No motions were raised or voted on, and no questions were asked about the annual report.
So, there was time and there was space.
Yet when a ratepayer tried to ask questions from the floor, she was told she couldn’t, because her questions needed to be sent in before the meeting.
Instead of allowing her questions to be heard – and answered or taken on notice – time was spent reading out legislative provisions explaining why they could not be asked from the floor.
Ironically, it would have taken less time to hear her questions.
When the shire president formally closed the meeting after 20 minutes, he then chose to speak to those remaining in the room.
Unsurprisingly, the ratepayer who was not allowed to ask questions chose not to stay and listen.
If you deny someone the right to be heard, they will naturally disengage.
Democracy can be messy: questions can be repetitive, they can be uncomfortable and they can test patience.
But respectful leadership requires a tolerance for scrutiny – especially at a meeting designed to give ratepayers a voice.
Toodyay residents are capable of forming their own views, but what they saw at this meeting appeared to focus more on procedure than participation.
Ratepayers deserve genuine engagement and they deserve respect.
At the very least, they deserve a meeting where someone presses ‘record’.

Community out of pocket after $195,000 lost in unclaimed GST

 

 

 

By Rashelle Predovnik
March 2026

An internal investigation is now under way after council rejected a request by the Toodyay shire administration to write off $195,000 in unclaimed GST owed to the shire by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).

 

Council instead voted to support a recommendation by the Audit and Risk Committee to do more investigation and get external advice.

The request to write off the funds as a loss was made because a four-year window open to claim the money has now closed.

Community cost

In response to questions asked at the December council meeting, the shire confirmed the loss would decrease the available funds which it would otherwise use to deliver services to the community.
“The community will have to bear the brunt of this in the 2025-26 year by reducing the amount of funds available for much needed community projects,” the shire said in a statement.
A report to the Audit and Risk Committee said (as part of council’s standard end of year procedure) a reconciliation should have been done to ensure that all monies owed to the shire by the ATO in the form of GST credits had been claimed.
“And if not, lodge revised Business Activity Statements (BAS) to ensure those monies are claimed and received by theshire,” the report said.
But an investigation found that no reconciliation of GST had occurred.
Records also showed there was a large amount of money held by the Australian Tax Office that was owed to the shire in the form of GST credits for purchases made by the shire.
The reconciliation showed that $633,000 was owed to the shire by the ATO dating back to 2020, according to the report.
The report also said under the ATO rules, the shire was only able to amend BAS returns dating back four years.
Funds owed from before December 2021 cannot be claimed by the shire and this equates to $195,000.
The report also noted that this credit should have been picked up by management when preparing the annual financial statements each year, but there was no evidence that this had happened.

One mistake spans two shire administrations

The historic failure to identify the money owed by December 2024 spanned successive shire administrations, including the current one.
Toodyay Shire chief executive officer Aaron Bowman told The Herald the matter was not brought to his attention by the then executive manager of corporate and community.
Mr Bowman said the issue only came to light when the current executive manager of finance and corporate services completed the year end GST reconciliation, at which point it
was formally reported to him.
The Herald questioned why the opportunity to retrieve some of the GST up until December 2025 had not been taken.
Mr Bowman said as the matter was only raised with him towards the latter part of 2025 the opportunity to act earlier had already passed.
“Additionally, the year end reconciliation process required significant time to complete, which further restricted the window for recovering any remaining GST,” he said

Wheatbelt Corella cull ruffles feathers

By Rashelle Predovink
March 2026

Flocks of corellas that once blanketed Toodyay’s landscape have been decimated in a coordinated cull, despite a last-ditch attempt by the Animal Justice Party to stop the mass shootings.
The cull coordinated by the Wheatbelt Natural Resource Management (WNRM) was done in partnership with the shires of Toodyay, Northam, York, Goomalling and Victoria Plains.

Cull slammed as “rushed and cruel”

But the program and the short notice given to the community has come under fire from Animal Justice Party WA MP Amanda Dorn who slammed the cull as cruel, rushed and ethically indefensible.
She said two out of the three species present in the region – the Western Corella and the Little Corella – were native to Western Australia.
“Both have expanded their range largely due to agricultural clearing and altered landscapes.”
“We have taken their land for farming, removed trees, altered water sources and changed landscapes, and now we plan to kill them for trying to survive in the environment we reshaped.
“Killing birds for responding to those conditions is not responsible environmental management.”
Ms Dorn said most significantly, public notice of the cull was posted on 17 February, just days before the scheduled killing.
“That is not meaningful community consultation,” she said.
“This is a major wildlife cull involving native species, yet residents have been given only days’ notice and limited information.”

Calls for more information and more options

Ms Dorn said Corellas flocked together and lethal programs risked harming many native birds indiscriminately.
“If culling is being described as a last resort, the public deserves clear evidence that alternatives were genuinely implemented and assessed.”
Ms Dorn said she acknowledged local governments had cited hefty infrastructure damage costs.
But she said if infrastructure was vulnerable, why hadn’t investment been made into infrastructure solutions?
“Modification, adaptation and habitat management are more ethical and often more sustainable than repeated lethal programs.”
The Animal Justice Party WA has called for the full public release of impact assessments and operational details and transparent reporting of proposed kill numbers as well as independent animal welfare oversight.

Cull was a necessary says WNRM

WNRM chief executive officer Renata Paliskis said wildlife management decisions were complex and she understood they could evoke strong and legitimate community perspectives.
Ms Paliskis said the Corella management project had been underway for several years in response to significant and escalating impacts associated with large Corella populations across parts of the Wheatbelt.
“These impacts include serious threats to biodiversity, displacement of other species such as the critically endangered and rapidly declining population of Carnaby’s Cockatoo chicks from nesting sites, and damage to agricultural infrastructure.”
Ms Paliskis said non-lethal methods used by local shires in the past included gas-guns, bendy men, scare tactics and drones.
But these methods didn’t work as the Corellas quickly become use to them and other humane methods were being explored.
Ms Paliskis acknowledged that community expectations regarding humane treatment of wildlife was evolving and she said ongoing scrutiny and improvement of the practice was appropriate.
Ms Paliskis also acknowledged the concern regarding the timing of the public notice.
“While communication occurred through participating local governments, we recognise that community expectations around consultation are increasing,” she said.
“This is an area where we are committed to reviewing our approach and strengthening transparency for future activities.”
Ms Paliskis said WNRM’s objective was to ensure management actions were evidence-informed, proportionate to the level of impact, undertaken responsibility and subject to ongoing review.
“WNRM is working closely with other partners on driving renewed conservation objectives in the Wheatbelt to promote the restoration of the necessary habitat for our local native species to thrive.”

1 2